Gauteng is losing 100 nurses each month, raising serious concerns about the region’s healthcare system. In February, the Minister of Finance announced an increase of R21.3 billion and R9.9 billion for health and education, aimed at protecting frontline jobs from budget cuts. However, a recent report reveals that even critical positions are being affected by the Treasury’s efforts to reduce debt through public spending cuts. The introduction of a proposed “fiscal anchor” could further exacerbate the situation, as it sets strict limits on state borrowing and spending.
This approach is likely to have dire consequences for healthcare services. The Human Resources for Health (HRH) Strategy predicts a shortage of around 97,000 healthcare workers by 2030 unless spending increases beyond inflation levels. The proposed fiscal anchor threatens to further jeopardise these essential roles.
To cut the public sector wage bill, early retirement packages have been offered to civil servants, aiming to swap older, more expensive employees for younger staff. However, data indicates that vacancies are not being refilled, suggesting that the early retirement initiative is more about reducing workforce numbers than renewing it. These voluntary packages often lead to the loss of experienced professionals, such as nurses and doctors.
In addition to the nursing crisis, Gauteng’s Estimates of Provincial Revenue and Expenditure show a decline of 2,899 medical personnel between 2024/25 and 2025/26. An analysis of budget data reveals most provinces now have fewer nurses than three years ago. Despite this, the Director-General of Treasury confirmed that South Africa has maintained a primary budget surplus for three consecutive years, even as schools, hospitals, and clinics face severe staff shortages.
The effectiveness of any budget should be measured not just in fiscal improvements, but in whether it aids or undermines constitutional rights. The Minister of Health previously stated that South Africa has only four doctors for every 10,000 people, significantly below the international benchmark of 10. Incremental budget increases only serve to delay necessary improvements.
The Finance Minister acknowledges that austerity can be counterproductive. Debt-to-GDP ratio is an unreliable measure, especially during economic downturns when GDP falls.
In a climate of stagnant economic growth and increasing population needs, there are concerns that a fiscal anchor could hinder improvements in socio-economic outcomes. Parliament’s Standing Committee on Finance has advised against adopting a strict fiscal anchor, which could restrict fiscal policy flexibility.
The focus should instead be on why South Africa pays such high interest on its debt and how to manage debt-service costs more effectively. These costs are projected to rise from 15% of expenditure in 2022/23 to 18% by 2028/29. The ongoing decline of the public sector under the guise of fiscal sustainability is proving ineffective in addressing the very issues it aims to resolve.
South Africa, one of the world’s most unequal countries, cannot afford to reduce the size of its state. Research from the Alternative Information and Development Centre (AIDC) highlights potential funding mechanisms that could alleviate the erosion of constitutional rights and help reduce servicing costs for debt.
As the next Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement approaches, there is a need to avoid past mistakes and ensure reforms do not further disadvantage an already struggling economy.
Aliya Chikte is a researcher at the Alternative Information and Development Centre (AIDC) and Deputy Chairperson of the Budget Justice Coalition (BJC).